Peachy Keen

We rented for the month and really like the accommodations. The rooms were spacious and nicely furnished and the kitchen was especially well-equipped. The outdoor space was very generous and the grill was a wonderful asset.

Peachy Keen is a terrific Key West destination. I and my family have stayed here two years in a row and are planning to make it three! The house is roomy and comfortable, and the backyard and pool are a slice of paradise. The house is a short walk from restaurants and Duvall Street, yet far enough away so that I can have privacy when I want it. Preferred Properties, which I have had a relationship with for decades, is a joy to work with. Peachy Keen feels like home to me. Can't wait to get back.

The house was great and in a great location. The TV was difficult to understand so we just used our netflix.

The house was great and in a great location. The TV was difficult to understand so we just used our netflix.

We love Peachy Keen! If you need a rental that can give you an escape and allow you to spend time together with extended family, this house is the one. We loved that the house had great shared spaces and an ability to retreat to your room for some of your downtime.


Peachy Keen's location is perfect. It is blocks away from some of our favorite restaurants in Key West; it is also close to the best beach in Key West, Fort Zachary. Yet it is located far enough away that you can retreat home to Peachy Keen when you are done for the day. We would spend days going on outings, then head home for afternoon naps and lounging by the pool, then back out for evening outings.


We have no complaints from our time; The Management staff answered any questions we had immediately after texting. It was so convenient to be able to text them any of my questions or concerns; it made me feel like I was not a bother. All in all, we enjoyed our stay due to so much I didn't even think about until writing this review: a clean house, a great location, a responsive staff, a warm pool, and a private area. So I can genuinely say we are very keen on Peachy Keen

This vacation home was our first time renting a home for an entire month, and we embraced everything the house offered, including the tasteful hints of Star Wars scattered throughout.
The house is in a fantastic location, just a block away from the Green Parrott and two blocks away from Duval Street. Nothing seemed too far. The pool was great, the backyard had a nice deck with a large gas grill, and the outdoor furniture was perfect for entertaining.
We hadn’t realized how easily the home could accommodate two couples with different ways to take in Key West. The second large bedroom has its own front door making it easy for one pair to stay out a bit later and not cause any disruption to those of us who went to bed early.
It took us a little longer to drive down than we expected, so the parking space was appreciated, but honestly, we used the car just two times while we were there.
The management company was exceptionally helpful and answered any questions we had. They had an excellent knowledge of Key West and even booked us an electric golf cart the week our oldest was in town.
A special shout-out to Angela, who put us at ease when we accidentally broke the coffee carafe on day 4. She replaced it the same day and explained how the damage plan we purchased provided coverage for this scenario.
The house has three bedrooms in the main home, two of which have their own bathroom. The third bedroom shares its bathroom with the central part of the house. The back cottage/pool house has a pull-down bed, a small fridge, and a toilet, transforming the space based on your need.
The kitchen has a great set of dishware and cookware, affording one the ability to prepare meals from home when you need a break from Key West’s phenomenal restaurants.
I look forward to visiting again as the experience was out of this world! I am now home and am glad I could relax for the month. The Force is strong with us!

I had the time of my life at this perfect getaway in the perfect location in paradise! No need for transportation other than Uber to airport because everything is walking distance, including groceries, restaurants and sites to see. You could comfortably sleep 8 and there is a nice living room/kitchen combo for hosting pre-party parties! I used the deck overlooking the pool for WFH, but it was hard to focus on work with so much to do nearby. Make sure you spend time at Ft. Zachary Taylor Beach, a 15 minute walk from Peachy Keen!

The best house I've rented on Key West. Nothing negative to say. The property was well maintained, clean, and just the right size. Its location was perfect: close to restaurants, watering holes, and Duval Street. Preferred Properties staff was responsive when anything needed to be brought to its attention. I will rent this place again. And again.